In principle, I think an electronic book device is a good idea.

In practice, it will clearly suck, as Mark Pilgrim has so ably demonstrated.

Just say no, damnit.

Comments:

actually, things are not that bad. First, Kindle is not the only option, Sony sells PRS-505. Then, inside is just linux. There are communities of PRS users and hackers who make new versions of OS images with different key mappings, updated fonts, new readers, localizations and all kinds of improvements. There is just linux inside, copy the image, mount and tweak it as much as you like.

And what makes it a really useful device is that -- somewhat in contrast to mp3 music -- there is a lot of DRM free content (wikibooks, gutenberg) that can be easily formatted for convenient reading on a 6-inch display. It's just a matter of a few weeks, maybe months for tools to appear.

Posted by david tolpin on 22 Nov 2007 @ 09:50am UTC #

Nonetheless, take a look at Alexander Falk's personal review of it:

http://www.xmlaficionado.com/2007/11/amazon-kindle-review.html

He may not be the most typical of users, but he focusses on what the device is like to use in practice, rather than on the philosophical questions (which have never been an impediment to iPod sales, it would seem).

Cheers, Tony.

Posted by Anthony B. Coates on 22 Nov 2007 @ 11:04am UTC #

There are plenty of other devices. Some of them under linux.

Posted by karl on 27 Nov 2007 @ 07:24am UTC #
Add a comment or subscribe to (existing and future) comments on this essay.
Name:
Email*:
 *Please provide your real email address; it will not be displayed as part of the comment.
Homepage:
Comment**:
 **The following markup may be used in the body of the comment: a, abbr, b, br, code, em, i, p, pre, strong, and var. You can also use character entities. Any other markup will be discarded, including all attributes (except href on a). Your tag soup will be sanitized...